Memory Foam Mattress Comparison

This memory foam mattress comparison pits Essentia vs Tempurpedic.

The comparison is best done with these two because Tempurpedic is the industry leader while only Essentia is offering a natural option.

The market is cluttered with many companies offering very similar products to Tempurpedic.

To simplify matters it is easy to break the memory foam mattress industry down into three categories.

First there is Tempurpedic, who were the pioneers of memory foam mattresses. Then there is Essentia, the only company offering natural memory foam. And then there is everybody else.

The major player in memory foam mattresses is Tempurpedic. They were the first to develop memory foam as a bedding material and from them all the copycats have spawned. Despite that they remain the dominant force. 

Essentia is unique in the memory foam mattress comparison as they are the only company to produce natural memory foam. They are a small and recent addition to this popular market but they are making ground.

Natural memory foam is actually natural latex that has a memory foam feel. It is not visco-elastic foam which is the petroleum based memory foam used by Tempurpedic, and what is widely regarded to be infered by the term "memory foam."

However Essentia refers to their product as "natural memory foam" because it has the same feel as visco-elastic foam. Thus it should be considered in a memory foam mattress comparison.

Producing Their Own Foam

memory foam mattress comparison
image by PhylG

Tempurpedic and Essentia are the only ones who produce their own foam.

All of the other companies purchase their from another manufacturer, and often it comes from China.

This is what places these two way out in front in terms of the best quality product in a comparison of memory foam mattresses.

They produce their raw materials to their own specifications and this means they can ensure premium standards. This makes them more expensive but that is because they are better. The copycats have tried to cash in on Tempurpedic's success by undercutting them. But all they have done is cut corners to create a cheaper product that is just not as good.

If you are on a tight budget and want memory foam then investigate one of the cheaper options. But ideally you should be prepared to spend a bit more money on a good mattress. It is worth it in the long run because it not only lasts many more years but is better for your health and improves your quality of life.

Natural Memory Foam

A variety of memory foam mattress producers make claims about their products being natural, green or eco friendly. The regular foam originally developed by Tempurpedic and still widely used is a chemical cocktail. That is why memory foam has that weird chemical smell.

Some companies replace a portion of the chemicals with a natural substance which is why they make their eco friendly claims. But at its heart the product is still petroleum based.

Essentia's competitive advantage is that it is the only company to produce a natural memory foam that is chemical free. Their foam is derived from natural latex and also use organic essential oils, water and plant extracts.

The key benefits of this are:

  • It's good for your health
  • It's biodegradable
  • It's good for the environment
  • It's not dependant on petroleum based ingredients
  • It sleeps cool and doesn't trap heat like regular memory foam

The Advantages of Tempurpedic

However Tempurpedic does advantages in that they have a slightly wider range, some at the lower end are cheaper and they do have a longer history. While Essentia claims their mattresses will last 20 years but that is hard to prove when the company hasn't been around that long.

On balance though Essentia wins out in the memory foam mattress comparison because the two are comparable on comfort, support and durability while Essentia is leagues ahead in terms of health and eco-friendliness.

› Memory Foam Mattress Comparison